top of page

Welcome to

Whisk(e)y Reviews

December 2022

with

Greybeards Top 5 American Whiskies of 2022

We all love the Top 5, 10, and 100 lists. The legendary David Letterman was known for the crazy top 10 lists he presented on his show, and every musician dreams of having a song reach the Billboard Top 100 list. Distilleries, Wineries, and Cigar blenders get excited when one of their creations ends up on a Top list from their fans and publications. 

​

However, every list can be subjective to the author’s taste or preference. Does the author like Ryes? Do they prefer old-world wines over new-world wines? When it comes to the world of whiskies, how does their profile differ from yours? As you read my Top 5 American Whiskies, you will likely ask yourself these questions.

​

In creating this list, I looked back to the whiskies I had tried throughout the year and which ones left a memory. I then went back to revisit several different whiskies. Was that memory worth revisiting, looking for overall balance in the profile, and most importantly, was this a whisky that I found worthy of wanting to share with my friends? Ultimately, I had to narrow the list down to five whiskies. This was challenging. I eliminated some excellent expressions, such as Blue Run Golden Rye, Larceny Barrel Proof Batch B-251, and Jack Daniels Single Barrel Select. Once I had my selections narrowed down to the following five, I returned to the memories, sat down with each of them individually, shared them with my friends, and began taking notes on the expressions themselves. 

​

So, as I sit here with a dram poured, putting the finishing touches on this article, I present my top five American Whiskies for 2022.

DSC_0007.jpg

Castle & Key Rye 2021 Batch 1

 

I know this is my top 5 whiskies of 2022; however, I am listing the Restoration Rye 2021 Batch 1 from Castle & Key here. What can I say? This Rye hits every single level for me, from proof to notes, spice to viscosity. I love a good solid Rye whiskey, and this one is one of my favorites.

https://www.castleandkey.com

​

Information: 

Age: 3.5 years

Release: 2021

Proof: 50.5% / 101 proof

Classification: Kentucky Rye Whiskey

Price: $50

Visual: Light golden honey

Aroma: Springy zesty citrus notes with subtle hints of vanilla and stone fruit

Taste: Crisp, sweet peaches, soft cream with a peppery finish

Feel: Medium-long finish with creamy, viscous mouth feel, finishing strong with warmth and spice

Penelope Architect Build 2

 

Penelope continues raising the bar with their expressions, and with the Architect Series, they have kept what is now a tradition going, as evident in Build 2. When Build 1 came out earlier this year, I knew I needed to grab a bottle. I was not disappointed. When Build 2 came out, I was on the hunt, finding it felt like I had just dug up a long-lost blueprint.

https://penelopebourbon.com

​

Information: 

Age:  No age statement (minimum of 4 years

Release: 2022 

Proof: 52% / 104 proof

Classification:  Straight Bourbon finished with French Oak Staves

Price: $60

Visual:  Medium golden amber

Aroma:Earthy woodsy notes with hints of citrus, herbal notes

Taste:Toasted oak with subtle hints of charcoal, and oily citrus, finishing with notes of sweet red fruit 

Feel:Medium silky, creamy vanilla finish

Kentucky Peerless Double Oak Bourbon

 

When I walked into the distillery, I wasn’t sure what to expect. I had only ever tried a single expression from Peerless. On this particular day, Corky, the fourth-generation owner, was there signing bottles. So like any other bourbon fan, I got in line for a bottle and an autograph. 

https://kentuckypeerless.com

Information: 

Age: No age statement (minimum of 4 years

Release: 2022 

Proof:  54.20% / 108.4 

Classification: Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Price: $135-$145

Visual:Deep Amber

Aroma:Oak, Vanilla, Orange zest

Taste: Oak, vanilla, nutty citrus, with white pepper on the finish

Feel: Long finish with creamy/buttery notes reminiscence of butterscotch

Kentucky Owl Tukami Limited Edition

​

This past September, I had the opportunity to go to the Kentucky Bourbon Festival in Bardstown, Kentucky. While there, I was able to enjoy whiskies from over 45 distilleries. While there were several exceptional pours, three of which are on this list, the one that stood out for me was the Kentucky Owl Tukami Edition.

https://kentuckyowlbourbon.com

​

Information: 

Age: a 4-year-old blend of 4, 5, 6, and 13-year-old bourbons.

Release: 2022 Limited

Proof: 50% ABV / 100 proof

Classification: Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Price: $135-$145

Visual: Deep golden – amber with long thin legs

Aroma: Cheery wood with hints of orange peel

Taste: Black cherries, oak, orange citrus, cooking spices, and finishing with black pepper and oaky tannins.

Feel: Medium finish with soothing warmth from the pepper and proof—a light creamy mouthfeel with a hint of oils.

Milam & Green Single Barrel 13-year Straight Bourbon Whiskey

​

If you are unfamiliar with Milam & Green Whiskey, stop what you are doing, find a bottle, and familiarize yourself with their various expressions. And the next time you are in Blanco, Texas, a small town outside of Austin, stop in the distillery and grab a bottle of their Single Barrel Straight Bourbon.

https://milamandgreenewhiskey.com

​

Information: 

Age:  13

Release: 2022 

Proof:  60.48% / 120.96

Classification:  Single Barrel Straight Bourbon

Price: $135-$145

Visual: Deep Amber

Aroma: Crisp woody pine notes with hints of orange peel

Taste: Hot buttery oils with herbaceous notes and citrus with hints of pepper on the finish

Feel: Medium finish with a buttery viscous mouth feel

Cheers, 
Greybeard

Subscribe to our publications - our weekly newsletter and our monthly magazine!

©2023 Published by:

Whiskey Bourbon Scotch Enthusiasts, LLC ™

All rights reserved

bottom of page